Wrestling Doesn't Have to "Look Real" to be Good, if You're a Nerd

Toxic Yaoi, Anime, and how Nerd culture has taken over wrestling fandom (complimentary).

Share
Wrestling Doesn't Have to "Look Real" to be Good, if You're a Nerd

Please don't roll your eyes or pat me on the head once you read this, but: I'm a 52-year-old consumer of pop culture. At this age, there's a lot of media that is simply not directed at me anymore. I'm dad age, but I don't have kids, so not only is a lot of pop culture not aimed at me, but it's not even aimed at anyone in my house. Therefore, it was only in the last week that, thanks to a stray BlueSky post from David Bixenspan, I learned the term toxic yaoi and how it's being used to contextualize some key AEW story arcs. To briefly summarize my very elementary, surface-level understanding of the concept: if yaoi is a term for stories that focus on male relationships with a sexual undercurrent, and yuri is the all-lady version, the toxic versions of both are, well, self-explanatory. Toxic yaoi/yuri is also a good blanket term for, I suppose, all of professional wrestling, but when it comes to AEW, the term doubly applies to the ongoing "Hangman" Adam Page/Swerve Strickland feud/love affair, and to a lesser degree, the long-term Will Ospreay/Kyle Fletcher saga that was the central focus of the Full Gear main event on November 14.

Like I said--I only just learned that this term is a thing in American anime fandom, so I'm not going to spend a whole blog post discussing something I have less than a passing understanding of, although there was a lot of material to mine at Full Gear. Honestly, Swerve's behavior toward Hangman all year has had the energy of the clingiest, most obsessive petty ex this side of Fatal Attraction, and the best moments of the Texas Death Match for the World Trios Title were any moment Swerve showed diabolical glee at having fully roped Hangman back into his orbit, all "if I can't be with you forever I will fight you forever I hate you I love you." The mid-match spot where Hanger and Swerve sat on chairs in the middle of the ring and just staple gunned each other's chests for 20 seconds or so was probably the kinkiest bit of fetish material wrestling fans will see all year.

A bloodied Swerve Strickland grins maniacally at "Hangman" Adam Page, happy to be back with his eternal dance partner once again
"I missed you so much, Hangman"

But I imagine if I start waxing philosophic about Will Ospreay inserting the photos from his crush journal into his main event entrance, or Kyle Fletcher screaming "I fucking hate you!" while goading Ospreay into a backslide for a near-fall, there may be some people out there arguing that the love story between those two is more of a brotherly love than anything sexual (see also: Will Ospreay vs. Callum Newman in New Japan), and I don't know what I'm talking about. So instead, I'm going to use this clear evidence of anime influence in my playfighting stories to bring up my favorite pro wrestler of all time: Bret "Hitman" Hart.

Bret will always be The Man in my book. The "technical wrestling" guys are always my favorites, from Bret to Flair to Danielson to Zack Sabre Jr. and Lee Moriarty, and there was a time in the WWF when Bret Hart was the peak ideal of that style. His matches with Curt Hennig and his brother Owen are comfort food for me, and his 1997 anti-America heel turn (where he was simultaneously a super-hot babyface hero in his native Canada) is one of my favorite storyline runs of all time. Hearing the Hitman trash America by saying "It's better here in Canada, where we take care of our sick and our old, where we still have healthcare" made my budding Socialist heart grow three sizes. And after a career that included getting famously screwed over by Vince McMahon and Shawn Michaels, and getting kicked in the head so hard by Goldberg that he had to retire and later have a stroke about it, he's basically out of fucks to give and has no filter when it comes to giving his hot takes about modern wrestling. I love him for it even though I often disagree with him. To wit: he was back on his "modern wrestling looks more fake" trip this past week, getting interviewed on the Johnny I Pro Show and once again lamenting how much better wrestling was when he was the one doing the wrestling:

“I know that I gave so much and tried so hard to make it real, and I have a hard time today when it’s not,” he said. “I don’t think those values are carried forward, and they’re moving on in a different direction now, where wrestling is starting to become hokey.”
Bret continued: “In the end, I’m a wrestling fan deep in my heart, and I like to watch a really good wrestling match that builds and tells a story and all that. And I don’t get that fix anymore. I’m not getting that at all from today’s wrestling.”
He went on to say that wrestlers today aren’t “trying hard enough anymore to make it appear real.” While he said that he loves a lot of wrestlers today, “maybe they could put a hold on once in a while.
“You know, actually put someone in a headlock.”

Setting aside the fact that there are plenty of modern wrestlers working a mat-based, so-called "realistic" style (and setting aside the fact that these guys are legends in the field and I'm just some shmoe), what I think Bret and a lot of wrestlers from the 80s or 90s (Jim Cornette comes to mind) don't seem to understand about modern professional wrestling is, well, a few things:

  • Even in the 80s, pro wrestling didn't look "real." It's had "fake" looking elements ever since Danno O'Mahoney invented the Irish Whip in the 1930s, at least. (In Bret's defense, though, no one else made an Irish Whip into the corner look more painful.)
  • Every generation of pro wrestler adds more fantastic elements to the form; back in the 1980s, guys like Ricky "The Dragon" Steamboat were side-eyed by the prior generation as "less believable" or "doing too much too fast."
  • While it's accepted as truth that wrestling maintained kayfabe until the early 90s, when Vince McMahon admitted in court that wrestling is a work in order to circumvent regulation by state athletic commissions, it's very much up for debate whether or not the majority of fans actually believed it was "real" before the power brokers fessed up.

But here's the thing – anyone, pro wrestler or pro wrestling fan, who claims that wrestling looks "less real" than it used to, is basing what looks "real" on what they saw when they first got into wrestling (see also: music fans who are certain that music isn't as good today as it was when they were younger and discovering music for the first time). And here's the important thing – it just doesn't matter, because wrestling fans aren't looking to pro wrestling for a "real fight" anymore, if they ever have.

What does any of this have to do with toxic yaoi or anime? Well, as I get into this, keep in mind that my theorizing here is based largely on vibes and what I have observed in wrestling fans and in the workers themselves over the last 20 years or so. I'm not in marketing for WWE or AEW so I don't know what sort of demographic information they use for selling ad space or anything. That said:

Professional Wrestling in 2026 is informed more by anime, video game, and comic book culture than it is by actual combat sports.

Screen shot from Virtual Pro Wrestling 2
Screen shot from Virtual Pro Wrestling 2

Let's be honest – if professional wrestling "looked more real" in the 1980s, the ascendance of mixed martial arts in the 1990s basically destroyed the illusion (despite pro wrestling adopting the tapout method of submitting once MMA made it the standard. Ever wonder why every submission in pro wrestling before about 1995 or so is a verbal "yes, I quit?"). Meanwhile, home video game systems advanced to the point where video games like WCW/nWo Revenge or WWF No Mercy (or if you were my level of nerd, a copy of Virtual Pro Wrestling 2 imported from Japan via eBay, which still works in my old N64, by the by) ensnared a whole new generation of wrestling fans whose older brothers probably introduced them to wrestling via gaming. Those same kids were watching Pokemon, Dragonball-Z, Yu-Gi-Oh!, etc. Thus, once those kids actually got in front of live action professional wrestling, they didn't see some gritty, realistic combat sport along the lines of UFC or professional boxing; they saw a cartoony fighting video game or anime made flesh. And a lot of those kids ended up becoming pro wrestlers themselves – not because they washed out of other sports, or because they were discovered bouncing at a strip club by some chain-smoking local rasslin' promoter who needed a new face, but because they saw real-life superheroes (hello, last 100 years of lucha libre) and said, holy shit, I want to do THAT.

On the left: Kyle Fletcher in a layered white leather jacket with pink fur and pink glasses, similar to the One Piece character Donquixote Doflamingo
(Image courtesy PW/MMA News on Facebook, if that wasn't obvious)

Need proof? Look no further than the level of cosplay in the average pro wrestler's gear these days. Kyle Fletcher blew up the anime boards with his Donquixote Doflamingo gear at All In in August. Swerve Strickland and Kris Statlander pick a new DC or Marvel superhero to base their gear on every PPV (and Rey Mysterio's been doing that every WrestleMania for years prior). Gabe Kidd recently told Chris Jericho on his podcast, Talk is Jericho, that WWE video games are what got him into pro wrestling in the first place. Bret Hart got into pro wrestling because it's what his dad, an old-school carny, did as the family business. I love all the wild stories about that Crazy Old Wizard, Stu Hart, stretching dudes in the dungeon until their eyes bled, but that was a different time. Bret was a talented cartoonist, but cartoons likely didn't get him into wrestling. It's different now.

I see or hear it all the time from a certain breed of fan – "I want to be able to suspend my disbelief." Well heck, me too! i said earlier in this piece that my favorite brand of wrestler is the classic mat tactician. But I love all sorts of pro wrestling, whether it's Mercedes Mone and Marina Shafir having a straight-up serious match of the night for the AEW Women's World Title, or if it's Yoshihiko taking on Minoru Suzuki. I've been watching wrestling since 1987. Yes, a lot of pro wrestling moves these days can only be done with obvious cooperation between the two (I hate to break it to all the Yoshihiko fans reading this, but their opponent does a lot of the work taking those moves). Sometimes it's a bit excessive for me too. Lord knows I start to snicker sometimes when a group of wrestlers stands together waiting for someone to leap off the top rope onto them. We all have degrees of realism that we'll accept in a pro wrestling match. But to assume that the degree that I accept is the correct amount would be a bit arrogant. Today's fan is accepting of a lot more bullshit than maybe even I am, and that's fine, because they found a different path to pro wrestling than I did. Pro wrestling isn't MMA, it's not boxing, it's not comic books, it's not video games – it's pro wrestling, and pro wrestling is something different to everyone who consumes it. To some, it's a clash of real-life super heroes; to others, a Street Fighter match with live people. To some, it's the most fun when it's a DMX-scored chaos hurricane. And most awesomely of all, apparently to more people than I realized, it's a series of doomed gay love affairs. That the wrestlers themselves are clearly leaning into all of this tells me that they dig it, they're having fun with it, and – this still being a carny biz, after all – can sell tickets with it.

This is probably the part where someone rebuts by pointing out that pro wrestling these days doesn't pull the same ratings that it did back when the wrestling was "more realistic" during, say, the Monday Night Wars, when lucha libre was taking hold in the zeitgeist and one of the WWF's top attractions was...*checks notes*...a porn star who faced potential castration from a gang of offensive Asian stereoypes. Yes, the insane TV ratings of the period where an undead funeral director with mystical powers derived from an urn would magically no-sell their opponent weren't the result of a much less fragmented entertainment landscape where streaming has supplanted most cable television options...it was because of more realism. Makes sense to me!

Pro wrestling is many things to many people, and that's why it will continue to thrive for generations more. And at the end of the day, if someone wants a wrestling match that "looks real," well, those are still out there! Someone put the Hitman in front of New Japan World and show him Ryohei Oiwa. You want a dude to put someone in a headlock, Bret? Get with The Grip; he's got you, my man.